Skip to main content

Why are we surprised that yet more migrants have drowned? It is a product of our animosity towards them


Throughout the past week, we have seen the political blame-shifting that the UK government has become accustomed to using as a panic-button since their election in 2019. In response to the most fatal loss of life of anyone crossing the Channel, Boris Johnson saw it fit to use Twitter to ask that France do more to take back migrants who reach the UK. 

The result has been a small-scale diplomatic row between the two countries, for both of whom the issue of migration has long been a contentious issue. France's hostility to so-called "others" has been reflected through domestic laws such as banning the burqa in 2014, whilst immigration as a topic has snowballed in UK political discourse since the seismic events of Brexit in 2016.

Perhaps I wouldn't make a good journalist, discussing this a week after the news cycle. Nevertheless, now that the political spiel has died down, it is of heightened importance to reflect on and humanise the 27 victims of a tragedy that should not really come as too much of a shock to anyone. 

For this is a regular occurrence, and the antipathy towards migrants in the UK has been illustrated through both political and social circles. Brexit language focused on "taking back control" of borders and "keeping them out", which is somewhat ironic given that the British were the colonisers who started shipping these migrants in for slave labour, in the first place. Even more ironic is the fact that migrant crossings in the Channel are higher this year than in the last five years, and it seems to be only increasing.

In social settings, I encounter ever-baffling arguments about migrants coming in for a "free-ride", to take advantage of "ordinary Brits" - as if ordinary in this country means to have white skin and like we are living in the 16th century. It can only be assumed that this knowledge has been indoctrinated into people by right-wing newspapers, whose purpose serves on finger-pointing and dividing, so much to the extent that they have forgotten the conditions that migrants put themselves through all to get the faintest chance of building a life in the UK.

Maybe it's worth a reminder. Imagine the conditions you must be facing in your homeland (if they even have one, given that millions are stateless) to want to drag young children on a boat no little secure than a paddling pool, through hundreds of miles of choppy, freezing sea just to get one chance. The odds feel like practically one in a million. 

Some will object to this with economic concerns, along the lines of "we don't have enough money to finance them". Maybe then we should not be spending hundreds of millions on a glorified expression of an outdated monarchy. Or voting to cut ties with our closest economic partners - and suffering supply issues as a result.
Credit: The Epoch Times

Others will suggest they ought not to be so stupid to attempt this, given the little chance of success. In actual fact though, they are sold a dream by crooks and conmen who profit through their deaths. And it's a measure of their desperation that they are willing to accept the chance of death rather than continue their current plight.

I get that most of my frustrations so far have been strawman arguments, but I think it's safe to assume these opinions are dominant in the UK. Anecdotally, I have no doubt that we can all recall situations in which family members, friends, or colleagues have said things along those lines.

Fundamentally, immigration always ends up becoming an emotive, political issue. And that's a trap that I probably fall into as badly as anyone else.

But for us to dehumanise these people, to dismiss their plight as any sort of human problem, shows a callous lack of humility for the place and privilege we find ourselves in. No-one decides their birthplace, whether that is within a prosperous country, or war-torn. 

People may want to worry themselves, about those who they can more likely identify with, and whose problems seem more valid. That is fine, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try to put ourselves in others shoes, empathise with their situations - and ultimately lobby for policies that will benefit not only them, but us too. There have been countless cultural developments aided by immigration, and many migrants who have been pioneers in their fields. 

Perhaps if better systems were in place to assist some of these people, tragedies of this ilk that are all-too-common may be prevented. The funding is there, but the drive and desire is not. 

Why is it a surprise when it becomes a media story every once in a while? Because every once in a while, we feel guilty and squirm in our feet at the grim realities of the world that this country sits back and lets happen. And then, we forget about the mothers, fathers, sons and daughters that could be any of us, but for a roll of the dice.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

As Western governments wilfully ignore events in Palestine, they have lost the trust of their own people - and crucially, the Global South

It does not take a genius to spot the obvious contradictions in geopolitical narratives of Western governments and media evident over the past few decades. The US' post-9/11 botched "war on terror", that created a generation of instability in the Middle East, has served as the driver for European countries to lament the subsequent influx of migrants and legitimise the xenophobic desires of far-right parties. More recently, the same states have rightfully isolated Russia for their invasion of Ukraine - despite the similarity to their atrocities after 2001. Yet in the past three months, they have managed to brazenly exhibit their hypocrisy to an extent that I, and evidently many others, find astounding. And any long-time readers will know I've been more than happy to highlight duplicity of Western countries on this blog, so that should tell you something about how bizarre recent events feel. Source: UNRWA, via The Wire In response to the militant group Hamas' terror...

With an election upon us, we must make sure to get some long-awaited change

 Hasn’t the last five years felt like a long time?  In the run up to the December 2019 General Election four and a half years ago, I remember using social media to say “do your own research, and go vote for whatever you believe in”. There was, and still is, some reason in that - youth turnout in politics is still so lamentably low, and it’s partly why we see political change that does nothing to help young people. So do please vote on Thursday. But perhaps I was overly naïve in the run-up to that election, because things are a lot different now. In 2019, I was disenfranchised with the political system, cynical of all politicians looking to support their own political careers. After the wave of Jeremy Corbyn’s unexpected result in 2017,  why was it to be too different this time? And would it have had that much of a consequence? The last five years have laid bare everything I could - and maybe should - have learnt before. There are no positive words to describe what Boris J...

Divisive politics: In defence of the "woke"

Waking up the morning of November 8th, to the new of Donald Trump's re-election as U.S President - I sighed. There was none of the shock or disappointment of his initial election eight years earlier, or the anger and incredulity of 6th January 2021, where Trump's emboldened supporters stormed the U.S Capitol building for the most ridiculous coup d'état attempt.  No, instead, there was a grim sense of inevitability about the most divisive figure in modern global politics becoming the most powerful man in the world for a second time.  Trump's election is symbolic. For this is a man who, since his formal intention to run for President in 2015 - has thrived on propelling division and hatred. Some of his many moments include  questioning  the legitimacy of Obama's birth certificate, making policy announcements on social media, and telling people to drink bleach to protect against COVID-19.  It comes at a time where society seems at a crossroads, as social media misin...