Skip to main content

Another year of overlooking history can teach us huge lessons. Whether we learn from them, is doubtful


It feels every year that I find myself lamenting end-of-year reviews for their clichéd and banal nature, for after all the calendar is an artificial concept - somewhat influenced by astrology - and needs little celebrating. I suppose it is an excuse to drink, which is why you're not reading this a few days earlier! Perhaps it is best for me to put that cynical perspective aside, because as with all of history, last year taught society a lot.

Or has it? As I reflect back at what unfolded in 2021, politically and socially, I can only draw a single conclusion. That humankind continues to repeat its mistakes.

With each passing rotation around the sun, we have more knowledge and power bestowed upon us on a world full of enrichment and opportunities for progress. The advent of technology has only accelerated that growth exponentially, through a combination of accessibility and sheer capability. As these ever-increasing complexities continue to dominate, we have become so attached to innovation and singularity. So attached that we are ignoring history and all the lessons that have come with it.

It's ironic, no, that we should have so much more knowledge (= power, as another cliché goes), and yet make so many more fundamental mistakes? Perhaps the surfeit of opportunities we have make this inevitable, but even so, it is damn infuriating.

Examples of this begin no closer to home than the life-changing pandemic that has engulfed our lives over the past two years. For one, people and governments have shown that they will, time and time again, ignore science.

Not only will people ignore science, but they will actively reject it and the proponents of it. Scientists supposedly "in favour" of lockdown (though that is a stupid phrase because you'd have to be overly naive and misanthropic to believe that any person wants their lives restricted), have received an abundance of abuse through emails, social media, even letters. I have seen that first-hand, and to downplay the impact of this on any person's mental wellbeing - as many have - is plain and simple gaslighting.

COVID-19, for all the heartache it caused, also fostered our compassion and togetherness - at least at its outset. Anecdotally, I can remember the small smiles people gave to me while out on our single form of permitted exercise, and the examples of camaraderie countries, cities, towns, neighbourhoods realised by a strangely united suffering.

Fissures have developed in this, through human nature no doubt. Once again, these small acts of kindness seem the exception rather than the norm. No further is that shown than that abuse.

Ironically, pandemic misinformation is a pure example of how history has been disregarded. It's easy to cite the 1918 Spanish Flu, but it's necessary. Some of the most basic methods used then, see masks, social distancing and quarantine, have been up for debate in the current pandemic. 

Not only that, but our reticence to acknowledge the continuing severity of COVID-19 is saddening. Perhaps that sentiment is born out of understandable tiredness at the upheaval in our lives, as many of us didn't expect an calamity this long-lasting. History though, again, tells us that the Spanish Flu lasted over two years. Notwithstanding our medical and vaccine achievements, the interconnectedness of the modern world always suggested more scope for a virus to spread than 1918.

The lessons we learn from misinformation are perhaps not felt by all, and least of all by the most privileged. Because these lessons come in the cost of the countless people lost to the virus, many of which were avoidable. The pain of their grieving loved ones is a stain upon the governments and people who refused to listen. That is a pain that will never be rectified and one can only wish that it haunts the consciences of those culpable, though we all know that is a miniscule possibility given that some were dining on wine and cheese throughout.

That a similar type of misinformation will eventually come to haunt our globe is the second dispiriting takeaway from 2021. Climate science suffers from the same subversion as epidemiology, and far from singularly impacting our own species, its ramifications extend to the whole ecosystem on earth.

I'm not much of a film-watcher, but I found Don't Look Up extremely powerful, as was its intended effect. Only after that do I realise how analogous the pandemic and the climate crisis have come to be. When you watch films of similar plotlines, you expect it to be fantasy. You expect to come away not thinking about the realities of the world. Yet while it immerses you in the story, the film entrenches the crushing reality of hopelessness that many feel about misinformation currently circulating.

For in the aftermath of COP-26, hyped up by the media and politicians as a landmark in the fight against climate change, that feeling is more pronounced than ever. Political agreements have already been reneged upon, and the aims are so vague that those in charge can claim victory no matter how little the progress. In some ways, this is symptomatic of global promises, for the Millennium Development Goals and birthchild Sustainable Development Goals, have similar ambiguity. Once more, history shows the bare-faced for all their falsehoods.

While we hope for future leadership to better these problems, while we campaign for more action to be taken, that sense of hopelessness continues to nag away. It is impossible to trust individuals who only care about short-term gain, electoral politics, and advancing their millions. 

For sure, the last year produced positives and they are to be cherished. Yet those positives feel hollow if we are going to make overshadowing mistakes that impact us as individuals and as a collective. I will continue to lament the continuing neglect of long-term problems on this blog, for I feel they are more important than all the day-to-day mania we get so caught up in. But that doesn't make me immune, for the idealism this piece craves is somewhat lost when my mind gets distracted.

It would be nice if the calendar wasn't that artificial concept that my cynicism perceives it. Because if we were to start again this year with all the people and planet reset and all the knowledge we gained, maybe we would do differently. Possibly though, we would continue to ignore history.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

As Western governments wilfully ignore events in Palestine, they have lost the trust of their own people - and crucially, the Global South

It does not take a genius to spot the obvious contradictions in geopolitical narratives of Western governments and media evident over the past few decades. The US' post-9/11 botched "war on terror", that created a generation of instability in the Middle East, has served as the driver for European countries to lament the subsequent influx of migrants and legitimise the xenophobic desires of far-right parties. More recently, the same states have rightfully isolated Russia for their invasion of Ukraine - despite the similarity to their atrocities after 2001. Yet in the past three months, they have managed to brazenly exhibit their hypocrisy to an extent that I, and evidently many others, find astounding. And any long-time readers will know I've been more than happy to highlight duplicity of Western countries on this blog, so that should tell you something about how bizarre recent events feel. Source: UNRWA, via The Wire In response to the militant group Hamas' terror

We must better consider all the people caught up in modern-day warfare

In some ways, this blog comes full circle to the very second post I wrote on  here circa six years ago .  That time, in the aftermath of the 2017 Las Vegas shooting, the blog focused on how names and stories appeal to our emotion more than facts and figures. Boy can I see the difference in writing style - 17 year old Kabir bizarrely quoted Stalin in making the point.  What I grappled with, and have done for a while since, is the unnatural and paradoxically natural emotional response to scales of tragedy. Hundreds of thousands dying is harder to comprehend than ten that are accompanied by names and faces. Yet more people dying is obviously worse globally. Ironically, I forgot the shooting’s details, which in itself encapsulates the point.  These limits of human empathy are (at least to me) fascinating, but they pose some problems in the globalised, interconnected world we now live in. In a world where our media consumption plays such a key role in how we perceive and interpret l

Light at the End of the Tunnel

It is never a bad thing to ask for help, contrary to what the mind, or even society, might say. Unfortunately for me, whilst sat there in floods of tears at my kitchen table, the whole tissue box I had emptied littered on the floor, I didn’t realise it. It was a Wednesday evening in late January, I had just gone through a day of school feeling perfectly content – bar the worries many teenagers find themselves under. I recall feeling focused in the three lessons I had that day, and playing football in the afternoon, I imagined, would only help my mood. After all, they do say exercise helps balance the chemicals in your brain. But I got home, sat down and genuinely considered suicide. What possibly is there left here for me? How is it ever going to feel like life is worth living? The weeks of building anxiety and depression had taken their toll. School stress, A-levels closing in. Social stress (ever-increasing in an age where social media has become habitual). Coupled with en